A WOMAN who killed her 10-month-old daughter by leaving her in a hot car as temperatures soared has been held in jail awaiting sentencing.
Michelle Nguyen, 21, was charged with the manslaughter of baby Thy Tran, who was left a car in a Glenroy driveway and died in November 2011.
Saul Holt, for Nguyen, today told Supreme Court Justice Betty King had already spent four days in prison and should not return there.
Instead, Mr Holt urged Justice King to consider placing Nguyen, who pleaded guilty, on a community corrections order with strict conditions.
The submission was rejected by Justice King who, after considering her decision for several hours, said a non-custodial sentence was simply not viable.
“I have come to the firm view a community corrections order is not a viable alternative,” she said.
Nguyen broke down as she was told she was being remanded in custody.
She was later helped from the courtroom to court holding cells by three prison guards.
Mr Holt had argued any non-custodial sentence could be the subject of strict conditions including community work, curfews and tough reporting conditions.
The submission was opposed by Crown prosecutor Mark Rochford, SC, who said the matter was “simply too serious”.
Justice King told the court that because of the seriousness of the offence it “absolutely warrants a sentence of imprisonment”.
She also raised concerns that Nguyen had been warned on several occasions not to leave her baby alone in the car.
The court heard Nguyen had fallen into the habit of regularly leaving Thy in the car in an effort to help her fall asleep.
But it was alleged she had been regularly warned against the practice by concerned family and friends.
On one occasion Nguyen’s stepfather had warned her that babies could die if left in hot cars unattended, but she continued to leave Thy alone in her car, the court heard.
The final warning was delivered on the day the infant died after she was rescued by a concerned neighbour, it was alleged.
“She had been warned on numerous occasions. Her stepfather had told her people die,” Justice King said.
“Other people had said, 'Don’t forget the child.'
“How much more (did) she need to be told? She knew it was wrong.”
On that day, Nguyen took her two children for a drive to try to get them to fall asleep and, upon her return home, removed her older child from the vehicle, leaving the sleeping Thy.
Nguyen checked Thy after about 15 minutes and then went inside, intending to return 15 minutes later, but she fell asleep watching television.
She later woke in a panic and ran out to find Thy unresponsive.
Paramedics could not revive the baby, whose temperature was found to be 41.5C.
Mr Holt said despite the tragedy Nguyen was a good mother who had made the “mistake she will regret for the rest of her life”.
Nguyen was remanded until February 12, when she will be sentenced.